All reviews have to be written in an electronic form and send to Editors via email: jmcbem@wz.uw.edu.pl. The evaluation form can be accessed here: download form.

Before you complete your evaluation form of the article, please take account of the guidelines given below.

Do you feel your expertise matches the problems covered in the article?  Accept an invitation from editor if you are competent to review the article.

Is there a potential conflict of interest? if you work in the same department or institute as one of the authors; if you have worked on a paper previously with an author; or you have a professional or financial connection to the article – please list all of this (or more) when responding to the editor’s invitation for review.

Do you have enough time? As the reviewing of an article can be quite time consuming, please make sure that you will have sufficient time before the deadline stipulated in the invitation to conduct a thorough review. If you feel the review will take you longer to complete than normal, please contact the editor to discuss the matter.

Ethical issues. If you suspect that an article is plagiarized work, please let the editor know, citing the previous work in as much detail as possible. Also if you suspect the results in an article to be untrue (because of e.g. data manipulation) discuss it with the editor.

Confidentiality. Any manuscripts received for review must be treated as confidential documents. Consequently, they must not be presented to, or discussed with, others except as authorized by the editor. Also, remember that unpublished materials disclosed in a submitted manuscript must not be used in a reviewer’s own research, unless the author(s) consent of has been obtained. Valuable ideas accessed through peer review must be kept confidential and not used for personal advantage.

Reviewer identity is not shared with the author.  We would like to keep your identity secret from the author(s). To help us protect your identity, please do not reveal your name within the text of your review.

Our Reviewers:

2017:

Marcin Awdziej

Joanna Chudzian

Marcin Gebarowski

Anna Jasiulewicz

Grzegorz Karasiewicz

Iwona Kowalska

Katarzyna Krot

Dariusz Siemieniako

Mariusz Trojanowski

Agnieszka Wilczak

2016:

Joanna Chudzian

Marcin Gebarowski

Grzegorz Karasiewicz

Iwona Kowalska

Katarzyna Krot

Anna Pawłowska

Dariusz Siemieniako

Mariusz Trojanowski

Rafał Zbyrowski

2015:

Joanna Chudzian

Natalia Gmerek

Gracz Leszek

Grzegorz Karasiewicz

Katarzyna Krot

Dariusz Siemieniako

Mariusz Trojanowski

Agnieszka Wilczak

Monika Zajchowska

Rafał Zbyrowski